Margarita Madness

With so many top-notch restaurants in the Valley, it’s no surprise that our quest to find the best margarita was a serious challenge. Here, a carefully culled panel taste-tests four of the Valley’s best and rates on a scale of 1 to 10.

  • Category
    People
  • Edited by
    Linda Grasso

 

 

 

Winner!

The Top Shelf Margarita

Larsen’s Steakhouse, Encino

Sure there’s tequila, but this beef emporium’s amazingly light margarita on the rocks almost tastes, well … dare we say it, like one of those pricey health juices people are sporting all over town. Here’s perhaps why: In lieu of syrupy bottled mixes, it contains one entire freshly squeezed lime as well as the healthy sweetener, agave nectar.
Michael: Refreshing and smooth, and I liked that the bartender asked if we wanted salt.
Sybelle: This is a margarita! Clean, smooth and fresh. Tastes like someone took the time to make something great.
Charlie: Outstanding. Fresh. Lots of different tastes. A complex margarita.

Score: 9.6

The House Margarita

Mexicali, Studio City

Bartenders at Mexicali use a homemade sweet and sour mix for the tangy House Margarita. Instead of lime juice, it is made with freshly squeezed lemon juice.
Michael: Fresh, and I like the inclusion of a little juice pulp. Could be a little sweeter.
Sybelle: Better than most. Tastes classic rather than “fresh.” Could use a bit more fresh juice.
Charlie: Solid. Not too heavy.

Score: 7.6

The Skinny

Casa Vega, Studio City

The Skinny is this popular watering hole’s contemporary take on their famous margarita. It eschews mixes in favor of fresh-squeezed juices. Lighter on the palate and the waistline. Also comes in a cucumber version.
Michael: The cucumber was my favorite of the night. Get it with the sampler plate!
Sybelle: Tastes simple and light, and you can really tell there are all-natural ingredients in it. Great on a hot day by the pool.
Charlie: Love it. Perfect amount of alcohol to juice and goes down really well with carnitas.

Score: 9.0

The Cadillac

Sol y Luna, Tarzana

Served by one of the Valley’s most popular traditional/no-frills Mexican eateries, The Cadillac yields no surprises. But think twice about having more than one; the bartender is generous with the tequila.
Michael: Might be a little strong for the average patron. Could use a little more lime.
Sybelle: Good but not amazing. Fresh lime juice would work miracles for this drink.
Charlie: Strong. Good taste and size. Could use a better sweet and sour mix or fresh instead of bottled lime juice.

Score: 6.3

 

More Stories

Snow White

Winter is just around the corner … and that means ski season. Here’s a guide to our favorite California slopes—here, near and up there.

Carmela Ice Cream Helps Cool Woodland Hills

Carmela Ice Cream co-founders Jessica Mortarotti and Zach Cox open their third location in Woodland Hills, featuring organic ice cream and specialty coffee.

Health

Fighting Back

Instead of living in fear or denial about cancer, try adopting the latest proactive cancer–fighting strategies that can reduce your chances of getting the disease.